For The Children: Why Encouraging Reading is Important
Adeline Zielke
You’ve been in an English class at least once in your life. There’s always that one kid (or maybe that kid was you!) that was told off by an English teacher, that their choice of book was not appropriate for silent reading time, and that they needed to pick something else. That kid, at least for me, always seemed to be holding Dork Diaries or Diary of a Wimpy Kid. That kid will then make a big deal of getting up, moving to the shelf, and spending the rest of the time staring at spines to find what to read next without actually picking a new book. What if I told you that when teachers make a big deal about what book a kid is reading, it will discourage them from reading in general?
Let me preface this by saying: if a teacher asks a student to use a book for a project or an assignment, the book has to up to par with the content that is being taught in the class; however, when a teacher asks the class for independent reading with a book of their choice, it is not up to the teacher to decide whether or not a book is appropriate to be reading at that moment. Independent reading time is for the student to read what they want, not what the teacher wants.
When kids read, it is typically because they like the book that they are working on. For me, I loved Wings of Fire, and I would read every book in the series over and over again. What is the difference between a student liking Wings of Fire and a student who likes Dork Diaries? To a teacher, one book is seen as challenging, whether it be for character dynamics, plot, or content, while the other is seen as immature. Despite the fact that both books are marketed for the same age. Preventing students from reading hinders their want to read in the future. A student who is criticized for their choice of reading is a student that will stop reading altogether. We should be reading challenging books, but forcing a student to put down a book they enjoy in order to read something else is not the right approach to take.
“So, what do you suggest?” I hear you yelling at your screen. Don’t worry dear reader, I have a solution! When teachers notice students who are reading at a level lower than what they would like them to read at, the teacher should instead, connect with the student, share what they love about the book they are currently reading, and then suggest recommendations similar to what they have now, so they can guide students to more challenging texts, while validating their choice in books. If you want the drama of Dork Diaries read a realistic fiction book similar to it. Roller Girl was another one of my favorites as a kid; it’s a graphic novel, but a great read! Spirit Hunters was another read that had drama, of a spooky kind. These suggestions are perfect to get a student excited for what they can look into next.
Nothing good that comes from telling a person they cannot read. Though teachers may have good intentions and want to challenge their students in reading texts that are more difficult, they discourage potential readers from continuing on their literary journey by creating a block of what they can and cannot read. Instead of telling a student no, offer more books that they will enjoy. That way there is a chance for them to be reading far later in life.