The Embarrassment of Being a Creative Writer
The Embarrassment of Being a Creative Writer
The Embarrassment of Being a Creative Writer
Jolene Reed
At some point or another—whether it is while shopping in the grocery store, eating Thanksgiving dinner, or attending core-required classes—every creative has faced judgement for their craft. This judgement comes in the form of incredulity or discouragement, confusion or doubt, and the challenge to “get a real degree.” The medium of creativity does not matter. No artist, musician, actor—or in my case, writer—is safe from criticism. Although culture hinges on art, rarely is the pursuit of creativity encouraged. The arts—especially in the age of Artificial Intelligence— are incredibly important, yet the world often fails to recognize their significance, leading non-creatives to label them as unnecessary and pointless labor. We are shamed for not choosing practicality over passion, as if a combination or balance of the two were impossible, and stand by, red-faced, as others slobber over writers like Stephen King, Sarah J. Maas, and James Patterson. Now, as I prepare to graduate with a Creative Writing degree, I find myself wanting to understand this embarrassment—where it comes from, why it exists, and most importantly, what exactly is so wrong or shameful about attempting to capture the human experience.
As with all artists, writers are faced with incredibly high definitions of success. In the eyes of others, success can only equate to fame or movie adaptations, a name with the weight of Stephen King’s or a signature worth enough for them to “sell for lots of money one day.” To them, writing is only honorable if it is profitable, and only successful if it makes you into a celebrity. This makes anything less feel like a failure. You can write your heart out and be good as gold at your craft, but if you don’t land on The New York Times Bestsellers list, something isn’t right, and it’s probably you. With this perspective, even standard or small victories can become embarrassing, and celebration of them a mere humiliation ritual.
For all this and more, writers often downplay their profession or deny it altogether. Embarrassment has made a liar of me more times than I can count. When asked what I am majoring in, I say that I am a standard English student instead of a Creative Writing major. If my own work comes up in conversation, I tend to change the subject or go into as little detail as possible. In environments where no one knows I am a writer, I choose to hold this card to my chest instead of play it—sometimes, I have even denied it when asked. I have committed perjury toward the art form I claim to love most and will likely do so a hundred times more.
As writers, it is our job to defend the right to read freely, write freely, and express ourselves. Some of our stories are designed simply to entertain; others inspire empathy and spread awareness of different cultures, issues, and perspectives. Literature is a vessel for change and a record of our place in time, yet like other creative work, is challenged or threatened all too often. For those who question literature’s relevance, novels like Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 and Emily St. John Mandel’s Station Eleven provide an answer.
Both novels depict very different dystopian worlds—the former, an alternate reality that completely bans and burns books; the latter, a post-apocalyptic landscape of survival. In Fahrenheit 451, independent thought and free speech are restricted. Stories survive by collective memorization via individuals committing literary passages to memory. It is only when they come together to share their fragments that full stories are told, that human connection is achieved and hope against their censored society is kept alive. Meanwhile, Station Eleven follows a traveling theatre troupe through the desolation of a world ravaged by deadly plague and lawless violence. The existence of theatre in the midst of an apocalypse is surprising, yet it is precisely this juxtaposition that emphasizes art’s significance.
If theatre, literature, and art truly contribute nothing to society, why do we find room for it in times of trouble? Why did American families flock to the movies during the Great Depression? Why did the Nazis burn books? Why are books still banned and censored today? If books are such an “outdated” art-form, why do we still allot them so much power?
Unless, of course, it is the power they have possessed all along.
Which brings us back to why—why would we as writers feel ashamed or embarrassed to wield such power, to express ourselves so meaningfully? Why should we deny who we are and what we do? Yes, not all roads lead to fame or immense wealth; on the contrary, many lead to rejection. Yet to continue writing, to never surrender what we love in the face of judgement, is crucial to both the survival of literature and the satisfaction of the creative soul. No embarrassment could ever be worth that. As you continue to write and grow, ignore others’ standards of “success” and create your own. Write not for them, but for yourself and your own happiness. And if, by some stroke of great luck or talent, your work is given the opportunity to be shared with others, consider it a pleasant and beautiful surprise.